Is Secession Constitutional?

This question may seem hard to many because they have been raised being taught, “If there is one thing we learn from the war between the states it is that we need to stay together.” It has been assumed that the Civil War answered the secession question, because some people who wanted to secede  were slaveowners.

The main point that one must remember is that the states are the ones setting the terms for the Federal Government. They are the employers, if you will, of the Federal Government. If you hire someone, even if it isn’t written in the contract, you can fire them. The contract that the colonies made with their federal government (otherwise known as the Constitution) lists the only rights that the Federal Government has, and also listed some very important rights the people have.  The federal government violated that contract, so it could and should be “fired”, or in other words, seceded from.  The only problem is that the federal government has shown what it does when somebody secedes, that is fight a war to keep them from doing so.  I don’t know if secession is worth a war that we would probably lose and be mistreated for.  Maybe we should just try to legislate the Constitution back.

Secession is constitutional.  Constitutional does not always equal right.  Constitutional usually equals right, but there are a few parts I would like to work to amend, after we get the basics down.  The North and the South were fighting for different reasons, and both were bad.  The Civil War was terrible, and fought for terrible reasons.  Although it freed the slaves, if America keeps heading down the track it is, everyone, blacks and whites, will be enslaved.

Are you going to choose to do something about it?


Is Compromise a Good Thing?

Compromise has no value, positive or negative, by itself. Compromise only exists in specific situations, and the matter of whether or not it is a good or bad thing lies in the situation.  This question is a parallel to the question, “Is saying, ‘The meeting is at 10:00 PM,’ a good thing?” Clearly, it is a good thing, if the meeting is indeed at 10:00 PM. If the meeting is not at 10:00 PM, then it is not a good thing. The entire value of it lies in the situation.

Likewise, if something good is gained through compromise, like getting part of a good cause done rather than none, and a little bit of necessary evil, then compromise is a good thing.  If the bad cause gains more from the compromise, it is a bad thing. If more bad is gained than good from any decision, (including making a compromise) don’t do it! There is more good than evil in the world, however, so most compromises are good. If more good is gained than bad from the decision, do it. If the net value of human joy goes up from a certain decision, then choose that path, or one that increases the net value of human joy even more. Finding out the result of your actions, then choosing the altruistic choice is the hard part.

Don’t meddle with other people’s affairs if you don’t have enough competence to make a decision. Study God’s laws to see which actions bring more joy.

My final answer is that compromise is not a good thing or a bad thing until the circumstance defines it, but it is a useful concept to have in your arsenal.

Where Does My Allegiance Lie?

My allegiance is to my God, and to the original Republic set up in the Constitution. It is always a bad idea to give your allegiance to anything that can change such as a person, or any non-divine entity for that matter.  The Republic that was set up in the Constitution will never change.  God will never change.

I know that Heavenly Father is perfect, and always will be perfect, because it has constantly been proven to me every time I pray, or am obedient to his commandments.

“For he is the same yesterday, today, and forever; and the way is prepared for all men from the foundation of the world, if it so be that they repent and come unto him,” says  1st Nephi 10: 18.

Common sense and the words of God show that the Constitution describes an ideal government, minus the unfortunate small compromises that had to be made.  Still, it is the best I have seen by far and I am willing to live in it and put my allegiance in it.  No matter what people do to change America it will never change the Republic for which the American flag stands.

My putting my allegiance in God does not mean I will be perfect at obeying him, because I am a sinner.  But putting my allegiance in him means I will repent when I do wrong.

Whenever someone puts their allegiance in something that is not God or created by him, they will inevitably sin and therefor suffer, but they can still always repent.

When Evil is Being Done is it Right to React With Evil?

12345It is never, in any situation, acceptable to do any form of evil.  The title of this essay is easy to answer.  The implied question in the title, however is not as easy:

1234512345What is Evil?

12345Or perhaps, a better question to ask might be: What is Goodness?  You and I are merely ignorant mortals.  We cannot hope to ever answer this question on our own.  The answer is really more like an array of answers and statements.  God has revealed many parts of the answer to this question through ancient and modern prophets, and personal revelation to other individuals.  A simplified answer is that Goodness is obedience to God, and Evil is disobedience to him.

12345Since this essay is for a class about the American Civil War, I am certain this question is preparation for discussing the way that the North treated the South during the war.  The implied question is: Was it okay for the Union soldiers to ravage the Southern countryside the way they did?  First of all, I would like to ask, why do we care?  Why should it matter to us wether or not the north was in the right or not?  Shouldn’t we only care about what we should do in our own lives?  Why, it’s our old hobgoblin, the “foolish consistency,” of course!  We Americans have been brought up being taught that the Northerners were the “Good Guys,” and that the Southerners were the “Bad Guys,” and being young, we accepted it.  If the North was evil, then that would mean that we were wrong that whole time we believed it!  Another thing causing us to wish that the Union soldiers were the Good Guys is a concept I read about in Ezra Taft Benson’s The Proper Role of Government.  He called it “Collective Guilt”.  Since we live in the Union, we feel somewhat responsible for any evils done by the Union in the past, and we feel uncomfortable facing that responsibility, that isn’t ours!  Don’t be ashamed, fellow Americans, for what those who came before you have done to their slaves and each other.

12345I do not think it was “okay” for the North to burn homes and fields of civilians, but I do not know one-hundredth of all the factors that went in to the war, so I am not in any place to answer that question.

Jace Wright, The Ignorant Scholar